Enhanced Status Code 4.2.1: Mailbox Disabled or Rate Limited - Temporary
Enhanced Status Code 4.2.1 means “Mailbox Disabled or Rate Limited - Temporary.” The recipient mailbox is not accepting messages right now. Gmail uses this specifically when a recipient is receiving mail faster than it will allow, which is a limit on them rather than on you.
450 4.2.1 The user you are trying to contact is receiving mail at a rate that prevents additional messages from being delivered
What does 4.2.1 mean?
Enhanced status code 4.2.1 is the temporary form of a mailbox that is disabled or not accepting messages. RFC 3463 registers X.2.1 for a mailbox that is disabled and not accepting messages, and the 4.x form says that state is expected to pass.
Google uses it in a way worth knowing about: 450 4.2.1 appears when a recipient is receiving email too quickly, when the recipient rate prevents additional messages, and when a peak SMTP relay limit has been exceeded. In the first two cases the limit belongs to the recipient, not to you. Someone signed up to many services at once, or a shared address is receiving from many senders, and Google is protecting that mailbox. Your reputation is not implicated and reducing your overall volume will not help.
The third case is different and is worth separating in your reporting. A peak SMTP relay limit is about your relay account rather than the recipient, and it does mean you are sending faster than the relay permits. If you see 4.2.1 concentrated on a small number of recipients it is the first kind; if it appears across many unrelated recipients at once it is the second.
How 4.2.1 plays out
4.2.1 replyWhere 4.2.1 sits: soft vs hard bounce
| Soft bounce (4xx) | Hard bounce (5xx) | |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Temporary | Permanent |
| SMTP class | 4xx | 5xx |
| What to do | Let it retry | Suppress the address |
| Recoverable? | Often | No |
| 4.2.1 is | ✓ this code |
What each provider means by 4.2.1
A registered code does not oblige a provider to use it that way, and the large ones diverge. Match the wording in your own bounce, not the definition above.
Common causes of 4.2.1
- The recipient mailbox is temporarily suspended or disabled
- The recipient is receiving mail faster than the provider allows
- A shared or role address is being written to by many senders at once
- Your relay account exceeded a peak sending rate limit
- The mailbox is being migrated or is briefly unavailable
- The recipient provider applies a per-sender-to-per-recipient hourly cap
How to fix 4.2.1
- Distinguish the two cases: concentrated on few recipients means their limit, spread wide means yours
- Let the queue retry, since recipient rate limits clear within hours
- Reduce per-recipient frequency if you are sending the same person many messages
- If a relay limit is named, spread the send over a longer window
- Do not suppress the address, since this is temporary and the mailbox is usually valid
- Watch for it becoming 5.2.1, which means the mailbox is permanently disabled